New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2014
The 25 Best Restaurants of 2014.
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2013
The 25 Best Restaurants of 2013.
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2012
The Top 25 Restaurants of 2012.
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2011
Top 25 Restaurants 2011.
Star-Ledger June 2011 – Four Stars
"From the moment you walk into Pluckemin Inn, it's obvious that this restaurant is about customer comfort."
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2010
25 Best Restaurants in NJ 2010
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2009
The 25 Best Restaurants in NJ 2009.
New Jersey Monthly Top 25 – 2008
The 25 Best Restaurants in NJ 2008
The New York Times – April 2008
"Pluckemin Inn is both indulgent and in the vanguard. It is a spot of Utopia with mostly persnickety standards."
Star-Ledger December 2007
"Pluckemin Inn hits all the right notes. BEST RESTAURANT IN NEW JERSEY 2007."